How Milu rates food additives
Milu separates documented concerns about certain additives from a preference for simpler formulations. This page describes the revised method dated 9 November 2026 for eligible, reviewed product records. Several methods may coexist during the beta; the explanation on a product result remains the reference for that product.
By the Milu team · Updated
Identify the additive and its use first
A Japanese name, a synonym and an E number may refer to the same substance. Milu matches the label declaration to its reference data and checks the required context. A generic declaration cannot establish an exact substance.
If identity or the relevant use is unconfirmed, the corresponding concern points remain pending. A rule about processed meat does not automatically apply to every similar word on a label.
Concern points in the revised method
Colours are Milu assessment categories. These points are planned before score limits for a distinct substance with confirmed identity and context. They are neither a measured dose nor a probability of illness.
Points for applicable concerns are added together. This method also applies a precautionary score ceiling of 49/100 when a red assessment is retained. These are Milu scoring choices, not a points system issued by WHO or EFSA.
| Retained assessment | Planned concern points |
|---|---|
| Yellow | 6 points |
| Orange | 15 points |
| Red | 30 points and a precautionary score ceiling of 49/100 |
| Unassessed or context unconfirmed | No documentary health points for that entry; no conclusion of harmlessness |
Why additive count is a separate consideration
Milu favours simpler formulations. The revised method plans no complexity points for the first two eligible declarations, then one point for each additional declaration, up to five. Teaching example: three eligible declarations plan one point; five plan three points; seven or more plan five points.
The count is a lower bound of distinct technological declarations recognised in the available text, not a complete molecule count. Duplicates and certain overlaps are excluded. A substance already penalised for a documented concern is excluded from complexity counting. An additive without a health colour may still contribute if eligible.
This penalty expresses a Milu preference. It does not measure an additive cocktail effect or prove that a combination is toxic.
Planned points and the actual score reduction
The engine compares a score without these deductions, a score with assessed concerns, and a score with complexity included. Score limits can absorb some planned points; the red ceiling can also make the final reduction larger.
The app separates planned points from the actual effect, assessing concerns first and complexity second. The final reduction cannot automatically be assigned to each additive individually. Nutrition and composition still work together: additive-free does not necessarily mean a high score.
Unassessed does not mean green
An entry with no assigned health assessment keeps no health colour. It receives no documentary concern penalty, but this establishes neither harmlessness nor harm. Unresolved declarations and unconfirmed uses remain visible limitations.
A label generally does not provide the amount of each additive. Presence alone cannot establish your actual exposure or compare your intake with an acceptable daily intake. The score does not certify a product as allergen-free or replace medical advice.
Sources, versions and corrections
JECFA, the joint FAO/WHO expert committee, and EFSA publish scientific assessments. These inform the reference data, but do not endorse Milu or its numerical weights. A European or international assessment does not by itself establish the regulatory status of a use in Japan.
The method is versioned and introduced in reviewed stages. Correcting identity, use or source data can change a result without a recipe change. Report an error through the app with the package information.